Public Policy Blog

Updates on technology policy issues

"Americans invented the Internet, but the Japanese are running away with it."

Thursday, August 30, 2007
Share on Google+ Share on Twitter Share on Facebook
Google
Labels: Net Neutrality , Public Policy Blog , Telecom

8 comments :

  1. John D GiottaAugust 30, 2007 at 5:55 PM

    Doubtful with the behavior towards technology. Its no different than the Ma Bell days, only nowadays elected officials care less about improvements and more about their wallets.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
      Reply
  2. Ian DanforthAugust 31, 2007 at 12:16 AM

    A faster internet benefits us all, however Mr. Whitt's argument takes us down a dangerous and discredited path.

    Competition is not the point.

    "[T]he U.S. has fallen behind its global competitors."

    Arguments like this reek of Cold War mentality. The internet is not a weapon with international reach, it is a unifying medium enabling us to confront human challenges rather than national or corporate ones.

    If Japan leads the pack, we catch up, not to beat them, but to aid them toward mutual goals. Petty fear of lost status and hurt pride are insufficient to this task.

    It is the brilliant promise of the internet and Google's own mission statement which demands we call not for a competition but a recognition of partnership between our nation and all who innovate.

    As we call for action from Washington and the boardrooms of AT&T and Comcast let's remember that every member of those bodies has something at stake here.

    Just as we do, they know someone who is dying of a disease being furiously researched around the globe. Just as we do, they know someone who can't afford a top flight college education. Just as we do, they know that the faster our tools of communication and the broader our choice of tools the faster we get these problems solved.

    That's what the internet provides, and that is why we fight this fight.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
      Reply
  3. QAugust 31, 2007 at 8:26 AM

    I think Google is DEAD WRONG on these public policy points. What would speed innovation in broadband access, would be deregulation of the current providers. There are MANY ways to get broadband into the home: cable, DSL, WiFi/Wimax, Satellite, electrical system, and probably a few we haven't thought about, because broadband access doesn't make much money for the CURRENT players. The problem with broadband, is that no one is making a ton of money doing it. If Time Warner were absolutely gouging its users, the VC industry would fund a cheaper more efficient way of getting broadband.
    You don't believe it? What do you think the "internet bubble" of 1997-2001 was all about?

    The cable companies are doing the best making some money in broadband, and this is why you see Verizon and AT&T investing the most cash into alternative broadband solutions. If you use ignorant politicians (they spend all their money figuring out how to get re-elected, not figuring out how to help constituents) to derail the profits Verizon and AT&T can make from their investments (something Google espouses), then you effectively kill entreprenuers desire to invest money into broadband access of the future. Nice going Google!

    Google's public policy is horrendous, self-serving, and worst of all, appeals to people's sense of entitlement. Broadband is a priviledge, not a right.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
      Reply
  4. Philip ShropshireSeptember 1, 2007 at 5:25 PM

    If Broadband isn't a right, then it should be. People without it will lose out in the future. Broadband is the "book" of the present and the future. Right now Europe and Japan have better "books". Of course, perhaps that's why they have smarter and healthier countries.

    I think Google is to be commended for what they're doing. Furthermore, even if they can't win the bandwidth with bids I would hope they would consider other options such as wi max, sat coverage, those broadband blimps that can never get off of the ground...don't give up. Would probably cost less than what you're bidding anyway....

    Philip Shropshire
    www.threeriversonline.com

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
      Reply
  5. Philip ShropshireSeptember 1, 2007 at 5:47 PM

    I might also add that the reason why Japan and Europe have better internets is that they control their corporations. If you define deregulation as the state having no control over multinationals, whether its shipping off American jobs or ditching must carry (which built the internet. It clearly worked...), then you have deregulation. And duopoly. There's also another word for when corporations run everything and that's called fascism.

    Philip Shropshire
    http://www.threeriversonline.com

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
      Reply
  6. UnknownJuly 16, 2009 at 11:40 AM

    The internet wasn't actually invented by Americans. It was invented by the British (London)-born Sir Tim Berners-Lee. Please correct your mistakes in this blog post.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
      Reply
  7. Alfredo GorgaJuly 24, 2009 at 7:39 AM

    "The internet wasn't actually invented by Americans. It was invented by the British (London)-born Sir Tim Berners-Lee. Please correct your mistakes in this blog post." Please check http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet , basically Americans "invented" the internet, and Tim Berners-Lee "invented" the web.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
      Reply
  8. UnknownAugust 17, 2010 at 5:44 PM

    Dear Google - if it WASN'T for an open internet in the first place..you wouldn't be &*(#^!! GOOGLE!! F>off.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
      Reply
Add comment
Load more...

The comments on this blog belong only to the person who posted them. We do, however, reserve the right to remove off-topic or inappropriate comments.

  

Labels


  • Accessibility 5
  • Ad 2
  • Advertising 11
  • AdWords 2
  • Anti-defamation league 1
  • Book Search 16
  • Broadband 11
  • Business Issues 26
  • Buzz 1
  • buzzemail 1
  • Canada 1
  • Child Safety 18
  • Chrome 1
  • Cloud Computing 2
  • Competition 19
  • Congress 10
  • Constitute 1
  • copyright 7
  • Cuba 1
  • Cybersecurity 9
  • D.C. Talks 16
  • Digital Due Process 1
  • Digital Playbook 1
  • Economic Impact 5
  • Economy 13
  • ECPA 4
  • Elections 24
  • email 1
  • Energy Efficiency 29
  • Europe 2
  • FCC 7
  • fellowship 2
  • Fighting Human Trafficking 1
  • Free Expression 54
  • Geo 1
  • Gmail 1
  • GNI 2
  • Good to Know 5
  • Google Fellow 2
  • Google for Entrepreneurs 1
  • Google Ideas 2
  • Google Maps 1
  • Google Policy Fellowship 1
  • Google Tools 78
  • Government Transparency 33
  • Hate Speech 1
  • Health 5
  • How Google Fights Piracy 1
  • Human trafficking 1
  • Identity theft 1
  • Immigration 1
  • Intellectual Property 19
  • International 46
  • Journalists 1
  • Malware 1
  • Maps 1
  • National Consumer Protection Week 1
  • Net Neutrality 24
  • Patents 5
  • piracy. ad networks 2
  • Politicians at Google 11
  • Politics 23
  • Privacy 93
  • Public Policy 1
  • Public Policy Blog 806
  • Safe Browsing 3
  • scams 1
  • search 3
  • Security 17
  • Small Businesses 3
  • spectrum 4
  • State Issues 5
  • Surveillance 6
  • Technology for Good 1
  • Telecom 71
  • Trade 3
  • Transparency Report 4
  • White Spaces 23
  • WiFi Network 1
  • Workforce 5
  • Yahoo-Google Deal 5
  • YouTube 4
  • YouTube for Government 1


Archive


  •     2016
    • Sep
    • Aug
    • Jul
    • Jun
    • May
    • Apr
    • Mar
  •     2015
    • Dec
    • Nov
    • Oct
    • Sep
    • Aug
    • Jul
    • Jun
    • May
    • Apr
    • Mar
    • Feb
    • Jan
  •     2014
    • Dec
    • Nov
    • Oct
    • Sep
    • Aug
    • Jul
    • Jun
    • May
    • Apr
    • Mar
    • Feb
    • Jan
  •     2013
    • Dec
    • Nov
    • Oct
    • Sep
    • Aug
    • Jul
    • Jun
    • May
    • Apr
    • Mar
    • Feb
    • Jan
  •     2012
    • Dec
    • Nov
    • Sep
    • Aug
    • Jul
    • Jun
    • May
    • Apr
    • Mar
    • Feb
    • Jan
  •     2011
    • Dec
    • Nov
    • Oct
    • Sep
    • Aug
    • Jul
    • Jun
    • May
    • Apr
    • Mar
    • Feb
    • Jan
  •     2010
    • Dec
    • Nov
    • Oct
    • Sep
    • Aug
    • Jul
    • Jun
    • May
    • Apr
    • Mar
    • Feb
    • Jan
  •     2009
    • Dec
    • Nov
    • Oct
    • Sep
    • Aug
    • Jul
    • Jun
    • May
    • Apr
    • Mar
    • Feb
    • Jan
  •     2008
    • Dec
    • Nov
    • Oct
    • Sep
    • Aug
    • Jul
    • Jun
    • May
    • Apr
    • Mar
    • Feb
    • Jan
  •     2007
    • Dec
    • Nov
    • Oct
    • Sep
    • Aug
    • Jul
    • Jun
    • May
    • Apr

Feed

Give us feedback in our Product Forums.

Company-wide

  • Official Google Blog
  • Europe Blog
  • Student Blog

Products

  • Android Blog
  • Chrome Blog
  • Lat Long Blog

Developers

  • Developers Blog
  • Ads Developer Blog
  • Android Developers Blog
  • Google
  • Privacy
  • Terms